Here's What You Should Buy at Aldi in the United States and What's Better at Costco

The eternal comparison between Aldi and Costco has resurfaced among American shoppers. A recent debate on Reddit gathered dozens of users who shared real experiences, comparing prices, quality, and convenience of these two supermarket giants.

The discussion began with a controversial statement: "The quality will never match Costco, but just looking at the price..." However, not everyone agreed. Many defended Aldi as a solid and more economical alternative, especially for small households or shoppers without the need for bulk products.

Price and Other Variables: Who Wins?

According to several comments, Aldi takes the lead when it comes to avoiding waste. Buying just what is necessary, without Costco's giant packages, allows for adjusting the weekly spending. One user claimed to spend between $70 and $110 per week at Aldi, while at Costco, they doubled that budget for the same recipes.

Other users highlighted that Aldi offers prices comparable to Costco, but without the need to buy in large quantities. For example, some basic products like flour or sugar can cost the same or even less at Aldi, although in smaller packages. This is ideal for those who don't have extra storage space, like a chest freezer.

Aldi: Ideal for Fresh Products and Small Purchases

Many agreed that Aldi is more convenient for basic and fresh products, especially for those living alone or as a couple. The ability to buy just enough, without falling into excess, avoids unnecessary accumulation and food waste. Additionally, its free membership is a strong point against Costco's annual fee.

Some users noted differences in meats and bakery, where Costco keeps an advantage. "You get what you pay for," said one comment, acknowledging superiority in Costco's products, although more expensive. Others, however, defended Aldi's quality in meats like chicken, sausages, or salmon.

Costco: For Big Purchases and Recognized Brands

Costco remains the preferred option for those who value well-known brands and buy in large volumes. Hygiene items, frozen goods, or durable products like toilet paper and paper towels have higher quality at Costco, according to several participants.

Additionally, those who plan ahead and have space to store find good prices per unit at Costco. However, several consumers indicated that those savings have decreased over time. Before, the difference per unit could be 20%, but today it is more narrow. In some cases, Aldi turns out to be cheaper, especially in products like milk or eggs.

What to Choose Then?

The majority agree that the choice depends on lifestyle. Aldi is practical, economical, and sufficient for many families. Costco offers quality and long-term savings but requires organization, space, and a higher initial expense.

If one seeks to cook at home, avoid impulse purchases, and keep a budget, Aldi seems the best option. If one prefers to buy in quantity and take advantage of brand-name products, Costco is hard to beat.